Knowledge hub › Three levels

One question, three levels of support

In every lesson, every student answers the same question about the same text. The three levels change the support around the task and leave the task alone. Here is the thinking behind that, and how to decide who starts where.

Illustration of a gentle hill with three footpaths winding up it, one with steps, one with a handrail and one steep, all meeting at a flag on the top

Long read · Updated · 6 minute read

Three levels of support means every student answers the same question about the same text, and only the support changes. Securing (aiming for a 4) has a word bank and sentence starters, Strengthening (grades 5 to 6) has prompts and a planner, and Soaring (grades 7 to 9) has no starters. The hinge question decides where each student starts.

Mixed classes are normal in English, and so is the pull towards writing three tasks: an easier one, a standard one and a harder one. It looks like good adaptation. The trouble is what it does to expectations.

The case against separate tasks

The Department for Education’s framework for new teachers is direct about it:

“Adaptive teaching is less likely to be valuable if it causes the teacher to artificially create distinct tasks for different groups of pupils or to set lower expectations for particular pupils.”

The same standard asks teachers to adapt lessons “whilst maintaining high expectations for all, so that all pupils have the opportunity to meet expectations”.

A separate, easier task decides in advance which students will meet the question that matters. A shared task with different support keeps the question the same for everyone and changes how much help each student gets on the way to answering it.

The same question for everyone“How does Dickens present Scrooge as cut off from other people?”

  1. Securingaiming for a 4A word bank, a choice of exact quotations, a worked example on another quotation, and sentence starters.
  2. Strengtheningaiming for grades 5 to 6Prompts for each part of the paragraph, a paragraph planner and a success checklist.
  3. Soaringaiming for grades 7 to 9A debatable statement to argue with, prompts towards other readings, and precise analytical verbs. No sentence starters.

The same task for everyoneOne What–How–Why paragraph

One question and one task for the whole class. Only the support changes.

The Education Endowment Foundation’s guidance on special educational needs makes a related point: “To a great extent, good teaching for pupils with SEND is good teaching for all.” Scaffolding is one of the five strategies it recommends, alongside explicit instruction, cognitive and metacognitive strategies, flexible grouping and technology.

What changes at each level

Here is the task page from Lesson 3 of the A Christmas Carol scheme in each student pack. The question is the same on all three: “How does Dickens present Scrooge as cut off from other people?”

The Lesson 3 task page in the Securing student pack

Securing

aiming for a 4

The Lesson 3 task page in the Strengthening student pack

Strengthening

aiming for grades 5 to 6

The Lesson 3 task page in the Soaring student pack

Soaring

aiming for grades 7 to 9

A Christmas Carol, Lesson 3: the task page in each student pack. All three are in the free Lesson 3 sampler.
  • Securing (aiming for a 4): a word bank with short definitions, a choice of exact quotations, a worked example on a different quotation, and sentence starters for What, How and Why.
  • Strengthening (aiming for grades 5 to 6): prompts for each part of the paragraph, a paragraph planner and a success checklist.
  • Soaring (aiming for grades 7 to 9): a debatable statement to argue with, prompts that push towards alternative readings, and precise analytical verbs. No sentence starters.

The worked example at Securing uses a different quotation from the ones students choose from. Students see every move a good paragraph makes, and they still have to make those moves themselves.

Naming the levels

Securing, Strengthening and Soaring are verb forms. Each names what the work is doing and the grade it is aiming for, which is a description of today’s task and says nothing fixed about the student. The levels are printed in words only, with no colour coding, so nobody spends Year 11 as the red group.

The evidence on grouping by attainment within a class is a reason for care. The EEF’s Teaching and Learning Toolkit puts the average impact of within-class attainment grouping at two months’ additional progress, from very limited evidence, and notes that “studies that measured literacy outcomes found no difference, on average”. It warns that without the flexibility to move between groups, some pupils “may suffer from a lack of confidence leading to lower engagement, and subsequently attainment”.

So the levels are a starting point for one task, and students move between them. The student packs tell students so: “Everyone in your class answers the same question in every lesson. Only the support changes, so you can move between packs as you improve.”

Myths about adapting for a mixed class

  • Myth Adapting for a mixed class means writing an easier task and a harder task.

    What the evidence says

    The DfE’s framework for new teachers says adaptive teaching is less likely to help if it causes the teacher to create distinct tasks for different groups or to set lower expectations for particular pupils. Keep the task and change the support.

    Source: Department for Education, Initial teacher training and early career framework (2024)

  • Myth Grouping students by attainment within the class raises literacy.

    What the evidence says

    The EEF Toolkit puts the average impact of within-class attainment grouping at two months’ additional progress, from very limited evidence, and finds that studies measuring literacy outcomes found no difference, on average.

    Source: Education Endowment Foundation, Teaching and Learning Toolkit: within-class attainment grouping

Deciding who starts where

The hinge question decides it. In Lesson 3, before anyone writes, the class answers a three-option question on mini-whiteboards: which reading of “solitary as an oyster” does the text best support? The teacher notes say what each wrong answer tells you.

From there the notes are specific:

  • Students who chose the literal reading, or who struggled with the Do Now, start on Securing.
  • Anyone who completes the Securing frame in ten minutes moves to the Strengthening prompts for a second paragraph.
  • Students who can already build a thesis start on Soaring.

The exit ticket closes the loop. At the end of Lesson 3, you sort the tickets into three piles to plan the start of the next lesson, so tomorrow starts from what students wrote today.

In practice

  • Give each student the pack that suits them, printed or as a PDF, and keep copies of the next level’s task page to hand so a student can move up mid-lesson.
  • Let a student try a level higher when they want to. The support they need is still there if the attempt stalls.
  • Share the model paragraph with the whole class at the end. Everyone sees the same standard, whatever support they had on the way.

Frequently asked questions

How do you differentiate in English without lowering expectations?

Give every student the same question about the same text, and change only the support around the task. The DfE’s framework for new teachers warns against distinct tasks and lower expectations for particular groups.

What support does each level get?

Securing has a word bank, a choice of quotations, a worked example on a different quotation and sentence starters. Strengthening has prompts, a paragraph planner and a checklist. Soaring has a debatable statement, prompts towards alternative readings and analytical verbs, with no starters.

How do I decide which level a student starts on?

Use the hinge question. Students who chose the literal reading, or struggled with the Do Now, start on Securing, and students who can already build a thesis start on Soaring.

Can students move between levels?

Yes, and they should. Anyone who completes the Securing frame in ten minutes moves to the Strengthening prompts, and the EEF warns that grouping without the flexibility to move can hurt confidence.

Why are the levels not colour coded?

The levels describe today’s task and the grade it aims for, and say nothing fixed about the student. Printing them in words only means nobody spends Year 11 as the red group.

Sources

Press / to search from any page, and Esc to close.