A Christmas Carol: videos to go with the book

Free videos to go with the Between the Lines revision book for A Christmas Carol. Watch one, then go back to the book and write: the exam is sat by hand.

Part 1

Start here

Watch the complete revision guide before you start the book.

A Christmas Carol: the complete revision guide 9:42Plays from YouTube once you press play. Watch it on YouTube
Read the transcript

This is the complete revision guide to A Christmas Carol for AQA GCSE English Literature. I’m Hannah, and I teach English. In one video you’ll get the plot, the characters, the themes, the context, the terms to know, every quotation worth learning, and what the examiners reward. Paper 1 Section B: one question on an extract and the novel as a whole (AQA’s wording; the paper prints the staves as chapters). 30 marks, about 50 minutes, no AO4.

Answers are placed in a level by best fit. Let’s start with the plot, part by part. Stave 1. Christmas Eve. Scrooge refuses Fred’s invitation and the charity collectors.

At home, Marley’s ghost, in chains, warns him that three spirits will come. Stave 2. The Ghost of Christmas Past: Scrooge as a lonely schoolboy, his sister Fan, Fezziwig’s ball, Belle ending their engagement and, years later, with her family. Stave 3. The Ghost of Christmas Present: the Cratchits’ dinner and Tiny Tim, Christmas in far places, Fred’s party.

The spirit warns that Tim will die if nothing changes, then shows Ignorance and Want. Stave 4. A silent phantom: businessmen joking about a death, Old Joe buying the dead man’s things, the Cratchits mourning Tim, a neglected grave with Scrooge’s name on it. Stave 5. Christmas morning.

Scrooge sends the prize turkey, promises money to the charity collector and goes to Fred’s dinner. He raises Bob’s salary, and becomes “a second father” to Tim, who does not die. Now the characters. Ebenezer Scrooge. A rich, miserly moneylender who learns, through the visits of four ghosts, to care for other people.

Jacob Marley. Scrooge’s dead business partner, who returns in chains to warn him. Bob Cratchit. Scrooge’s underpaid clerk; a loving father who stays cheerful in poverty. Tiny Tim.

Bob’s young son, who is disabled and seriously ill; his fate depends on Scrooge’s change. Fred. Scrooge’s nephew, who keeps inviting him to Christmas dinner and refuses to give up on him. The Ghost of Christmas Past. A strange, glowing spirit who shows Scrooge his lonely childhood, Fezziwig and Belle.

The Ghost of Christmas Present. A jolly giant surrounded by food, who shows Scrooge how others keep Christmas, and reveals Ignorance and Want. The Ghost of Christmas Yet to Come. A silent, hooded phantom who shows Scrooge his lonely death and Tiny Tim’s.

Belle. The woman Scrooge was engaged to, who leaves him because he loves money more than her. Mr Fezziwig. Scrooge’s first employer, whose generous Christmas ball shows what a good master can do. The themes.

For each one, here’s the idea in a sentence. That sentence is the start of a thesis. Social responsibility. We are responsible for each other; the rich cannot ignore the poor. Redemption and change.

Anyone can change if they face the truth about themselves. Poverty and class. Dickens shows the poor as people with dignity and attacks the systems that failed them. Family. Families, rich or poor, have the love that Scrooge has shut out.

Christmas. A time for generosity and community, and a symbol of the values Dickens wants kept all year. The context. Use it where it explains a choice the writer made. One clause inside a point does more than a paragraph of history.

A Christmas Carol was published on 19 December 1843. Under the Poor Law Amendment Act of 1834, the workhouse was meant to become the main form of help for poor people who could work. Conditions were made harsh on purpose. Thomas Malthus argued in 1798 that population grows faster than the food supply. Some readers used this to argue against helping the poor.

When Dickens was 12, his family was deep in debt: he was sent to work in a blacking warehouse, and his father was imprisoned in the Marshalsea debtors’ prison. In 1843 Dickens read a government report on children’s working conditions and visited the Field Lane Ragged School in London. In October 1843 he spoke in Manchester about education for working people, shortly before he began writing the novella. The terms to know. Name a method only when you can say what it does.

Stave: A verse of a song. Dickens calls his five chapters staves, so the novella is shaped like a carol. The exam paper from AQA calls them chapters, so Stave 3 is printed as Chapter 3, and the question says the novel as a whole. Narrator: Talks to the reader with humour from the first line, “Marley was dead: to begin with.” In Stave 2 he stands “in the spirit at your elbow”. Allegory: Characters who stand for ideas, such as Ignorance and Want (Lesson 20).

Juxtaposition: Contrasts side by side: Scrooge’s small fire against Bob’s, “so very much smaller that it looked like one coal” (Lesson 5). Listing: Words piled up into a judgement: “a squeezing, wrenching, grasping, scraping, clutching, covetous, old sinner!” (Lesson 3). Pathetic fallacy: The fog and cold of Stave 1 against the “clear, bright, jovial” morning of Stave 5. Cyclical structure: Stave 5 returns to the people of Stave 1, so readers can measure the change (Lesson 28). Didactic purpose: Writing to teach.

In the Preface Dickens hopes to “raise the Ghost of an Idea”, and that it will “haunt their houses pleasantly”. The quotations. These are the 15 I’d want every student to know by heart. For each one: who says it, where, and why it matters. “solitary as an oyster”.

Narrator, 1. Simile: Scrooge is closed off, but an oyster can hold a pearl. “Bah!” … “Humbug!”. Scrooge, 1.

Scrooge dismisses Christmas, and with it kindness and community. “decrease the surplus population”. Scrooge, 1. Echoes Malthus; Scrooge sees the poor as a number, not as people. “Mankind was my business”.

Marley’s Ghost, 1. Marley realises too late that caring for others was his real job. “I wear the chain I forged in life”. Marley’s Ghost, 1. Metaphor: every selfish act added a link; we make our own punishment.

“A solitary child, neglected by his friends, is left there still.”. Ghost of Christmas Past, 2. The young Scrooge was lonely; Dickens builds sympathy. “The happiness he gives, is quite as great as if it cost a fortune.”. Scrooge, 2.

Scrooge praises Fezziwig and begins to see what a good employer is. “Another idol has displaced me”. Belle, 2. Money (a “golden” idol) has replaced love in Scrooge’s heart. “God bless us every one!”.

Tiny Tim, 3. Tiny Tim’s blessing includes everyone, even Scrooge. “If he be like to die, he had better do it, and decrease the surplus population.”. Ghost of Christmas Present, 3. The spirit throws Scrooge’s own words back at him.

“This boy is Ignorance. This girl is Want.”. Ghost of Christmas Present, 3. Allegory: society’s neglect of poor children will lead to its own doom. “Beware them both”.

Ghost of Christmas Present, 3. A direct warning to Scrooge and to Dickens’s readers. “I will honour Christmas in my heart, and try to keep it all the year.”. Scrooge, 4. Scrooge’s promise at the grave: the moment he decides to change.

“I am as light as a feather”. Scrooge, 5. Simile: the weight of his old life has gone. “He became as good a friend, as good a master, and as good a man, as the good old city knew”. Narrator, 5.

Repetition of “good” shows how complete the change is. Finally, what the examiners reward. AO1, response. An argued answer to the question, set out in a thesis, with short references from the extract and other staves. Both bullets matter, in either order: students do not have to start with the extract.

A how far question needs a judgement. AO2, methods. How Dickens makes meaning: the narrator, the stave structure, the spirits and contrast as well as single words. Level 6 analysis is convincing, critical and exploratory. AO3, context.

Context in AQA’s wide sense: the ideas in the question, 1840s London, the ghost story, readers then and now and the novella’s universal ideas. Use it where it explains Dickens’s purpose. One clause inside a point does more than a paragraph of history; examiners ask for Malthus and the Poor Laws in a sentence. And how answers lose marks: Retelling the plot; treating Scrooge as a real person with no writer behind him; staying in the extract; context bolted on at the end; pre-learned paragraphs that do not fit the question. That’s everything in one place.

Watch it again in a week, and pause on any section you couldn’t have explained yourself. Everything in this video comes from our A Christmas Carol scheme of learning for schools. If you’re a teacher, Lesson 3 of every scheme is free at btl.education. Thank you for watching.

Part 2

The novella and its context

The story, the characters, the themes and the words to know, a minute or so each.

A Christmas Carol, stave by stave, in about a minute 1:17Plays from YouTube once you press play. Watch it on YouTube
Every character in A Christmas Carol, in a sentence each 1:20Plays from YouTube once you press play. Watch it on YouTube
Every theme in A Christmas Carol, in one sentence 0:48Plays from YouTube once you press play. Watch it on YouTube
Christmas Carol terms, starting with why Dickens calls his chapters staves 1:32Plays from YouTube once you press play. Watch it on YouTube
Part 3

Quotations to learn

Watch these alongside Part 5 of the book, Quotations to learn.

A Christmas Carol: 22 key quotations explained 14:41Plays from YouTube once you press play. Watch it on YouTube
Read the transcript

These are the key quotations from A Christmas Carol, one from every lesson in our scheme that studies a moment closely. I’m Hannah, and I teach English. For each one we’ll do what the exam rewards: name the method, zoom in on one word, say what effect it has, and explain the writer’s purpose. Method, zoom in, effect, purpose. Try each one yourself before I explain it.

Pause the video when the quotation appears, and fill in the four boxes in your head or on paper. “Are there no prisons?”. The method: A rhetorical question. Scrooge answers a request for help with a question about punishment. Zoom in: “prisons” are for criminals.

Scrooge’s first thought is to lock the poor away. The effect: Readers see that Scrooge treats being poor as if it were a crime, which makes him seem heartless. The context: Dickens’s father was imprisoned for debt. Dickens gives Scrooge the harsh view of poverty he wanted readers to reject. “solitary as an oyster”.

Narrator, 1. The method: A simile that compares Scrooge to a shellfish. Zoom in: “solitary” means alone. Dickens shows that Scrooge chooses to shut people out. The effect: An oyster is clamped shut and hard to open, so readers see Scrooge as closed off and cold.

The purpose: An oyster can hide a pearl. Dickens hints that something precious is locked inside Scrooge, which prepares us for his change. And why it matters for the exam: Simile: Scrooge is closed off, but an oyster can hold a pearl. “decrease the surplus population”. Scrooge, 1.

The method: Scrooge uses the cold language of economics to talk about human beings. Zoom in: “surplus” is a word for leftover goods. Scrooge talks about people in need as if they were spare stock. The effect: Readers are shocked by how calmly Scrooge accepts that the poor might die. The context: Malthus argued that population grows faster than food.

Scrooge echoes this thinking, and Dickens makes it sound heartless. And why it matters for the exam: Echoes Malthus; Scrooge sees the poor as a number, not as people. “fellow-passengers to the grave”. The method: A metaphor that pictures all people as passengers heading for the same destination. Zoom in: “fellow” means companion or equal.

Fred puts rich and poor side by side. The effect: Everyone ends at the grave, so readers are reminded that money cannot separate them from the poor. The purpose: Dickens places this shortly before Scrooge says that those who would rather die should “decrease the surplus population”, so readers compare the two views. “Mankind was my business”. Marley’s Ghost, 1.

The method: Repetition. Marley says “business” five times in one short speech, widening its meaning each time. Zoom in: “Mankind” means all people. Marley now sees that every human being, including the poor, was his responsibility. The effect: The short, blunt sentence sounds like a confession, so readers feel the weight of Marley’s regret.

The purpose: Scrooge told the collectors “It’s not my business”. Through Marley, Dickens insists the poor are everyone’s business. And why it matters for the exam: Marley realises too late that caring for others was his real job. “a great extinguisher for a cap”. The method: A symbol.

An extinguisher is a metal cone placed over a candle to put out its flame. Zoom in: “extinguisher” names something made to put out light. The spirit carries the means of hiding its own light. The effect: Readers sense a struggle between light and darkness: the past can be lit up for Scrooge, or covered over again. The purpose: The Ghost counts Scrooge among those “whose passions made this cap”, suggesting he has smothered his memories for years.

“A solitary child, neglected by his friends, is left there still.”. Ghost of Christmas Past, 2. The method: An echo. The Ghost uses “solitary”, the word Dickens chose for the adult Scrooge in Stave 1. Zoom in: “neglected” means not cared for.

Someone should have looked after this boy, and nobody did. The effect: Readers begin to pity Scrooge. The loneliness he chose as a man was forced on him as a child. The purpose: Dickens shows that Scrooge’s coldness has a cause. The word “still” hints that the lonely boy has never left him.

And why it matters for the exam: The young Scrooge was lonely; Dickens builds sympathy. “He has the power to render us happy or unhappy”. The method: Antithesis. Scrooge sets opposites side by side: happy or unhappy, light or burdensome, a pleasure or a toil. Zoom in: “power” shows Scrooge understands that an employer has real control over his workers’ lives.

The effect: Readers see that kindness is a choice: Fezziwig could make work a misery, and he chooses to make it a pleasure. The purpose: Dickens speaks to employers among his readers. Scrooge has the same power over Bob, which is why he thinks of his clerk. “Another idol has displaced me”. Belle, 2.

The method: A metaphor. Belle compares Scrooge’s love of money to an idol, a false god that people worship. Zoom in: “displaced” means pushed out and replaced. Money now fills the place that Belle once held. The effect: Belle speaks “softly”, so the break-up feels sad and final.

Readers sense what Scrooge has thrown away. The purpose: The Bible warns against worshipping idols. Dickens presents greed as a false religion that costs Scrooge love. And why it matters for the exam: Money (a “golden” idol) has replaced love in Scrooge’s heart. “a glowing torch, in shape not unlike Plenty’s horn”.

The method: A comparison that links the spirit’s torch to a famous symbol from classical myth. Zoom in: “Plenty’s horn” is the cornucopia, a horn overflowing with fruit and food. The capital P makes Plenty a person. The effect: The torch seems to pour out light and good things, so readers see the spirit as a giver. The purpose: Malthus warned that population would outgrow the food supply.

Dickens answers him with overflowing plenty. “But, they were happy, grateful, pleased with one another”. The method: Structure. The narrator lists everything the family lacks, then turns with the conjunction “But”. Zoom in: “grateful” stands out: the poor family give thanks for what they have, unlike wealthy Scrooge.

The effect: The list of what they lack makes their happiness more striking. Readers remember the love more than the poverty. The purpose: Dickens challenges the idea that the poor are idle or to blame. The Cratchits have the love Scrooge lacks. “If he be like to die, he had better do it”.

Ghost of Christmas Present, 3. The method: An echo. The spirit repeats Scrooge’s words from Stave 1, “they had better do it”, but aims them at one child. Zoom in: “he” is Tiny Tim. Words Scrooge once aimed at a faceless crowd now land on a child Scrooge cares about.

The effect: Scrooge “hung his head”. Readers feel how cruel the words are once they have a face. The context: Malthus’s ideas were used to argue against helping the poor. Dickens gives the “surplus population” a face. And why it matters for the exam: The spirit throws Scrooge’s own words back at him.

“waking or sleeping, good or bad”. The method: Pairs of opposites. Together the two pairs cover every possible man on the ship. Zoom in: “good or bad” means the kindness reaches even the men who do not deserve it. The effect: Nobody is left out, so readers feel that Christmas is shared by everyone, even far out at sea.

The purpose: If Christmas can reach the “bad”, it can reach Scrooge. Dickens prepares readers to believe that he can change. “This boy is Ignorance. This girl is Want.”. Ghost of Christmas Present, 3.

The method: Allegory. The children are named after ideas, so they stand for problems in society. Zoom in: “Want” means poverty: lacking food and warmth. Dickens is not describing a greedy child. The effect: Two short, matching sentences sound like a verdict, and readers cannot dismiss the children as two unlucky individuals.

The context: In 1843 Dickens visited the Field Lane Ragged School, so it is telling that the spirit warns most about the boy, Ignorance. And why it matters for the exam: Allegory: society’s neglect of poor children will lead to its own doom. “the Spirit neither spoke nor moved”. The method: A negative structure. “neither” and “nor” tell us what the spirit does not do.

Zoom in: “spoke”: the first two spirits talked to Scrooge and answered him. This one gives him nothing. The effect: Stillness and silence make the spirit seem like a corpse, or like Death itself, so Scrooge fills the silence with fear. The purpose: Dickens makes Scrooge work out the lesson for himself. The future is not explained; it depends on what Scrooge does next.

“rings and all, with him lying there”. The method: Dialogue. The most shocking detail comes out in Joe’s surprised question. Zoom in: “lying there”: the body was still in the bed while the charwoman pulled the curtains down around it. The effect: Readers are disgusted.

Even Joe, who buys stolen goods, is surprised by how far she has gone. The purpose: Dickens shows the consequence of a selfish life: a man who cared for nobody has nobody to protect him, even in death. “I will honour Christmas in my heart”. Scrooge, 4. The method: A vow in the first person and the future tense.

Scrooge says “I will” four times in this extract. Zoom in: “honour” suggests respect and duty. “heart” places the change inside Scrooge, where Stave 1 placed “The cold within him”. The effect: His desperate cries give way to firm promises, so readers sense that he has finally decided. The purpose: Christmas stands for kindness, and “all the year” stretches it beyond one day.

The vow speaks to readers too. And why it matters for the exam: Scrooge’s promise at the grave: the moment he decides to change. “I am as light as a feather”. Scrooge, 5. The method: A simile: the first of four in a row, each beginning “I am as”.

Zoom in: “light” means weightless. The “ponderous chain” that Marley warned Scrooge he was forging seems to have fallen away. The effect: The comparison is playful and childlike, so readers share Scrooge’s relief and laugh with him. The purpose: Dickens presents change as a release. He wants readers to believe that kindness could lighten their lives too.

And why it matters for the exam: Simile: the weight of his old life has gone. “in his accustomed voice, as near as he could feign it”. The method: A narrative aside: the narrator lets readers know that Scrooge is acting. Zoom in: “feign” means pretend. His old, “accustomed” voice is now a part he has to play, and he can only manage it “as near as he could”.

The effect: Readers are let in on the joke, so we enjoy Bob’s fear while knowing that the old Scrooge has gone. The purpose: Dickens turns the miser of Stave 1 into a role Scrooge can barely perform. This makes the change feel deep and lasting. “May that be truly said of us, and all of us!”. The method: Direct address: in the final lines the narrator turns from Scrooge to the reader.

Zoom in: “us” is repeated, and “all of us” leaves nobody out. A story about “him” becomes a story about the reader. The effect: Readers are asked to measure themselves against Scrooge, who learned to “keep Christmas well”. The context: In 1843 Dickens visited the Field Lane Ragged School. The ending turns his anger at child poverty into a challenge to readers who could help.

“a spring-time in the haggard winter of his life”. The method: A metaphor based on the seasons: Scrooge imagines a daughter bringing new life to his lonely old age. Zoom in: “haggard” means worn out. Winter suggests old age and the cold that lived “within him” in Stave 1. The effect: Readers feel the warmth Scrooge has missed.

His “sight grew very dim”: he is crying. The purpose: Family love is the warmth Scrooge’s money could never buy, so the spirit uses it to begin thawing him. “Who suffers by his ill whims! Himself, always.”. The method: Fred asks a question and answers it himself, in just two words.

Zoom in: “Himself” is the word to zoom in on: Scrooge’s meanness hurts Scrooge most, because it cuts him off from love. The effect: Fred sounds wise and forgiving, so readers start to pity Scrooge as well as dislike him. The purpose: Dickens makes Fred the voice of the Christmas spirit: kindness that refuses to give up on anyone. Pick the five you find hardest and write a What–How–Why paragraph on each this week: a point, the quotation with its method and one word zoomed in on, and the writer’s purpose. Every quotation and explanation here comes from our A Christmas Carol scheme of learning for schools.

If you’re a teacher, Lesson 3 of every scheme is free at btl.education. If this helped, give the video a like and subscribe for more quotation videos and full revision guides. There’s another video on screen now to watch next. Thank you for watching.

Fifteen Christmas Carol quotations to learn, and why each one matters 2:26Plays from YouTube once you press play. Watch it on YouTube
Part 4

Model answers explained

Write your own answer first, then watch.

A Christmas Carol: three model answers, Level 3 to Level 6 17:07Plays from YouTube once you press play. Watch it on YouTube
Read the transcript

This is the end-of-unit essay from our A Christmas Carol scheme, with three complete model answers: one at Level 3, one at Level 4 and one at Level 6. I’m Hannah. I’ll read each answer, then tell you why it sits in that level and what would move it up. The question is: Starting with this extract, explore how Dickens presents Scrooge’s change in A Christmas Carol. It’s worth 30 marks, and you have 50 minutes.

In this extract, from Stave 5 (Chapter 5 on AQA’s papers), Scrooge has just woken in his own bed on Christmas morning, after the visits of the spirits. Here it is. “I don’t know what to do!” cried Scrooge, laughing and crying in the same breath; and making a perfect Laocoön of himself with his stockings. “I am as light as a feather, I am as happy as an angel, I am as merry as a schoolboy. I am as giddy as a drunken man.

A merry Christmas to everybody! A happy New Year to all the world. Hallo here! Whoop! Hallo!” He had frisked into the sitting-room, and was now standing there: perfectly winded.

“There’s the saucepan that the gruel was in!” cried Scrooge, starting off again, and going round the fireplace. “There’s the door, by which the Ghost of Jacob Marley entered! There’s the corner where the Ghost of Christmas Present, sat! There’s the window where I saw the wandering Spirits! It’s all right, it’s all true, it all happened.

Ha ha ha!” Really, for a man who had been out of practice for so many years, it was a splendid laugh, a most illustrious laugh. The father of a long, long line of brilliant laughs! “I don’t know what day of the month it is!” said Scrooge. “I don’t know how long I’ve been among the Spirits. I don’t know anything.

I’m quite a baby. Never mind. I don’t care. I’d rather be a baby. Hallo!

Whoop! Hallo here!” He was checked in his transports by the churches ringing out the lustiest peals he had ever heard. Clash, clang, hammer; ding, dong, bell. Bell, dong, ding; hammer, clang, clash! Oh, glorious, glorious!

Running to the window, he opened it, and put out his head. No fog, no mist; clear, bright, jovial, stirring, cold; cold, piping for the blood to dance to; Golden sunlight; Heavenly sky; sweet fresh air; merry bells. Oh, glorious! Glorious! Before the answers, here’s what a marker is looking for in this question.

A marker looks for a clear thesis about how and why Scrooge changes, then analysis that moves between the extract and the whole novella. In the extract, strong answers explore the run of similes (“I am as light as a feather”), the rebirth image (“I’m quite a baby”) and the clear weather (“No fog, no mist”) that replaces the fog of Stave 1. Across the novella, look for the cold imagery of Stave 1, the promise at the grave in Stave 4 and the actions that prove the change in Stave 5. The best answers treat structure as a method and link context to Dickens’s purpose. And here’s how I’d plan it.

Spend 2 minutes reading the extract twice. Underline three quotations that show Scrooge’s change and label the method in each. Spend 2 minutes writing a one-sentence thesis: how does Scrooge change, and why does Dickens want readers to see it? Spend 5 minutes planning three or four points. You can start with the extract or elsewhere, but you must cover both the extract and the novel as a whole.

This extract comes from Stave 5, at the end of the book, so starting with Scrooge in Stave 1 and reaching the extract later often works better. For each point, note one quotation or close reference. Add context only where it explains Dickens’s choice, and keep it to a clause. Use the last minute to number your points so your essay follows a clear order. Then start writing.

The pitfalls to avoid. Spending most of the 50 minutes on the extract and leaving too little time for the novella as a whole. Retelling the story of Scrooge’s change instead of analysing how Dickens presents it. Adding a paragraph of context at the end instead of linking it to Dickens’s purpose throughout. Misquoting from memory.

A short, accurate quotation is better than a long, inaccurate one. The first answer was written at Securing, the level of support for students aiming at a grade 4. It sits in Level 3, explained, structured comments. In A Christmas Carol, Dickens presents Scrooge’s change as a change from a mean, cold man into a happy and generous one. The ghosts show him his past, his present and his future, and this makes him want to be a better person.

In the extract, Dickens shows that Scrooge is very happy. He says “I am as light as a feather, I am as happy as an angel”. This is a simile. It shows that Scrooge feels free, as if nothing is weighing him down any more. The holy noun “angel” suggests that he has become good.

Dickens also uses lots of exclamation marks, such as “Whoop! Hallo!”, which show how excited he is. He is “laughing and crying in the same breath”, which shows he has lots of feelings at once. Scrooge also says “I’m quite a baby”. This shows that he feels like he has been born again and can start his life again.

A baby is innocent, so this suggests Scrooge has a fresh start. The weather has changed as well, because there is “No fog, no mist”. At the start of the novella it was foggy and cold, so the clear weather shows that Scrooge has changed too. At the start of the novella, Scrooge is very different. Dickens describes him as “solitary as an oyster”, which means he is alone and does not let anyone in.

He will not give money to the charity collectors and says that if the poor would rather die, they should “decrease the surplus population”. This shows he does not care about poor people. The ghosts change him by showing him things like Tiny Tim, who might die, and his own grave. At the grave he promises “I will honour Christmas in my heart”. At the end of the novella, Scrooge is kind and generous.

He sends a turkey to the Cratchits and tells Bob “I’ll raise your salary”. In Victorian times, many poor people had to go to the workhouse, and Dickens wanted rich people to help them. He uses Scrooge’s change to show readers that they should be generous too, especially at Christmas. So why does it sit there, and what would move it up? This answer sits in Level 3 (Explained, structured comments): it stays relevant, uses quotations from several staves and explains what each one shows.

Methods such as the simile and the exclamation marks are named, but their effects are explained simply and the zoom on single words is brief. Context is general and comes at the end, and parts of the last two paragraphs retell events instead of explaining Dickens’s choices. To move up, it needs a clear thesis, closer analysis of one word in each quotation, and context linked to Dickens’s purpose inside each paragraph. The second answer was written at Strengthening, for students aiming at grades 5 and 6. It sits in Level 4, clear understanding.

Dickens presents Scrooge’s change as complete and joyful: the cold, isolated miser of Stave 1 becomes a warm and generous man by Stave 5. Through this change, Dickens shows his readers that anyone can become more caring, and that the rich have a duty to help the poor. In the extract, Dickens presents Scrooge’s change through a list of similes: “I am as light as a feather, I am as happy as an angel, I am as merry as a schoolboy.” The repetition of “I am as” makes his happiness build up, as if he cannot stop. The feather suggests that a weight has been lifted, which reminds the reader of the heavy chain Marley wears in Stave 1. Scrooge has escaped the punishment his greed was creating for him.

The simile “merry as a schoolboy” also matters, because in Stave 2 he was a lonely boy left at school, so now he gets back the happiness he missed as a child. Dickens also presents the change as a rebirth. Scrooge says “I’m quite a baby” and “I’d rather be a baby”, which suggests he is starting his life again, fresh and innocent. This happens on Christmas Day, which celebrates the birth of Jesus, so his new start has a religious meaning. The weather supports this: “No fog, no mist; clear, bright, jovial”.

In Stave 1 the fog “came pouring in at every chink and keyhole”, so this pathetic fallacy shows that the gloom has left Scrooge’s life. The change is striking because of how Scrooge is presented at the start. Dickens describes him as “Hard and sharp as flint” and “solitary as an oyster”, similes that show he is tough and closed off. He tells the charity collectors that if the poor would rather die, they should “decrease the surplus population”, which echoes the ideas of Thomas Malthus. The spirits gradually break down this hardness.

In Stave 3 he asks about Tiny Tim “with an interest he had never felt before”, and in Stave 4, at his own grave, he promises: “I will honour Christmas in my heart, and try to keep it all the year.” Stave 5 shows that he means it. Dickens proves that the change is real by showing Scrooge’s actions. He promises the charity collector a large donation, explaining that “A great many back-payments are included in it”, which suggests he wants to make up for years of meanness. He tells Bob, “I’ll raise your salary, and endeavour to assist your struggling family”. This matters because in 1843 many workers were very poor, and under the 1834 Poor Law the workhouse was meant to become the main form of help.

Through Scrooge, Dickens shows wealthy readers how much difference a generous employer can make. By the end, the narrator says Scrooge became “as good a friend, as good a master, and as good a man, as the good old city knew”. The repetition of the plain adjective “good” shows how complete the change is. Dickens presents Scrooge’s change as proof that it is never too late to change, and he wants his readers to change too. So why does it sit there, and what would move it up?

This answer sits in Level 4 (Clear understanding): it has a clear thesis, explains well-chosen quotations from across the novella and keeps answering the question. Methods such as the similes and pathetic fallacy are explained clearly, with useful links back to Stave 1. Context about Malthus and the Poor Law is accurate and linked to Dickens’s purpose, though it is explained more than explored. To reach Level 5, it needs a more developed idea about what kind of change Dickens presents, closer analysis of single words, and more on structure. The third answer was written at Soaring, for students aiming at grades 7 to 9.

It sits in Level 6, convincing, critical analysis and exploration. Dickens presents Scrooge’s change as a second birth. The man who was “solitary as an oyster” in Stave 1 wakes on Christmas morning to find that “the Time before him was his own, to make amends in”, and soon calls himself “quite a baby”. The extract captures the overflowing joy of that moment. Across the novella, however, Dickens shows that the change has been earned through the spirits’ lessons and must be proved through action, and he ends by turning Scrooge’s rebirth into a challenge to his readers.

The extract presents change as a release of feeling that Scrooge can barely control. He is “laughing and crying in the same breath”, a paradox which suggests that emotions frozen since Stave 1 are thawing all at once. The run of similes, “I am as light as a feather, I am as happy as an angel, I am as merry as a schoolboy”, gathers speed through repetition until he is “as giddy as a drunken man”, as if his joy has outrun his dignity. The buoyant adjective “light” reverses the image of Marley’s chain: Scrooge has been freed from the “ponderous chain” he spent his life forging. The youthful noun “schoolboy” is just as pointed, because it restores the childhood happiness that the “solitary child” of Stave 2 was denied.

Dickens frames this joy as a rebirth. Scrooge declares “I’m quite a baby”, and the short sentences that follow (“Never mind. I don’t care.”) have a childlike rhythm. Waking on Christmas Day, which celebrates the birth of Christ, gives his new life a religious meaning. The narrator even calls his laugh “The father of a long, long line of brilliant laughs”, language of family and descent that hints at the “second father” he will become to Tiny Tim.

The setting is reborn too. “No fog, no mist” undoes the opening stave, where fog “came pouring in at every chink and keyhole”. In Stave 1, “No warmth could warm, no wintry weather chill him”; now the cold is “piping for the blood to dance to”. Scrooge can feel the world again. Although the change bursts out in Stave 5, Dickens builds it gradually so that it convinces.

In Stave 2, Scrooge weeps “to see his poor forgotten self”, an early crack in his hardness. In Stave 3, he asks about Tiny Tim “with an interest he had never felt before”, and when the spirit throws “decrease the surplus population” back at him, he is “overcome with penitence and grief”. At the grave in Stave 4, his language becomes a vow: “I will live in the Past, the Present, and the Future.” Early in Stave 5, Scrooge repeats those exact words as he scrambles out of bed, so the joy of the extract is a promise being kept. Dickens also insists that feeling must become action, and he shapes Stave 5 as a point-by-point answer to Stave 1. The charity collector Scrooge dismissed is now promised a donation with “A great many back-payments” included, a dry noun phrase from accounting that shows Scrooge using the language of business to repay a moral debt.

Fred’s invitation, refused in Stave 1, is accepted with the humble question “Will you let me in, Fred?” Bob, who once had a fire so small “it looked like one coal”, is told to “buy another coal-scuttle”. For readers in 1843, when the 1834 Poor Law was meant to give the able-bodied poor little but the workhouse and Malthus’s ideas were used to argue against helping them, these acts model the personal generosity Dickens wanted from people with money. The closing paragraphs confirm the change through repetition: Scrooge becomes “as good a friend, as good a master, and as good a man, as the good old city knew”, a progression from private friendship to his role as an employer to his whole moral character. Tiny Tim, “who did NOT die”, proves that the future the last spirit showed could be rewritten, and the capitals insist on it. Finally, the narrator turns to us: “May that be truly said of us, and all of us!” Scrooge’s rebirth becomes Dickens’s argument that his readers, too, still have time to make amends.

So why does it sit there, and what would move it up? This answer sits in Level 6 (Convincing, critical analysis and exploration): its thesis, that the rebirth is earned and must be proved, shapes every paragraph. It zooms in on single words such as “light” and “schoolboy”, and treats structure as a method, showing how Stave 5 answers Stave 1. Context is woven into Dickens’s purpose, and the quotations range across all five staves. To push it further, a student could weigh an alternative view, for example that the change is too sudden to be believable, before showing how the novella’s structure answers it.

When classes sit this essay, the same three things come up in the feedback. Give the novella as a whole as much space as the extract. Zoom in on one word in each quotation and explain its effect. Link context to Dickens’s purpose inside each paragraph, instead of adding it at the end. And here’s the improvement task for each level.

Find the one that matches your own answer, and redraft one paragraph in green pen. Levels 1 and 2: Pick one quotation from the extract, such as “I am as light as a feather”. Write three sentences: what it shows about Scrooge, which method Dickens uses, and how Scrooge was different in Stave 1. Levels 3 and 4: Redraft one paragraph so it moves from the extract to another stave. Add a quotation from Stave 1 or Stave 4, zoom in on one word, and end with what Dickens wanted his readers to do.

Levels 5 and 6: Rewrite your introduction as a thesis about the kind of change Dickens presents. Then redraft one paragraph to analyse structure: how Stave 5 answers Stave 1, and why Dickens wants readers to notice. This essay, the level guidance and all three models are part of our A Christmas Carol scheme of learning for schools. If you’re a teacher, Lesson 3 of every scheme is free at btl.education. Thank you for watching.

What a marker looks for in an essay on how Scrooge changes 2:02Plays from YouTube once you press play. Watch it on YouTube
What examiners reward in a Christmas Carol essay 1:23Plays from YouTube once you press play. Watch it on YouTube
Part 5

The exam and writing your argument

How Paper 1 works, how to start an essay with a thesis, and a plan for the last twelve weeks.

AQA English Literature Paper 1 explained

4 minutes · captions available

The Shakespeare play and the 19th-century novel: the extract-to-whole question, timing, and what examiners reward.

How to write a thesis statement for any GCSE English Literature essay 3:38Plays from YouTube once you press play. Watch it on YouTube
Read the transcript

If there’s one sentence that changes a Literature essay, it’s the first one. I’m Hannah, and I teach English, and this video is about the thesis: how to write one for any GCSE English Literature question. A thesis is your answer to the essay question in one sentence. It goes at the start of your essay, and every paragraph after it gives evidence for it. A good thesis is an argument that someone could disagree with.

That’s the test. If nobody could disagree with it, it’s a fact, and a fact gives your essay nowhere to go. Here’s the formula. It has three steps, and each one matches one of our levels of support. Step one, Securing.

The writer presents, then the character or theme, as, then your idea. Make a clear claim that uses the words of the question. Step two, Strengthening. Add in order to, and the writer’s purpose: what did they want the audience or reader to think, feel or do? Step three, Soaring.

Add yet, and a complication or a change across the text, then in doing so, and what the writer achieves. Now your argument has somewhere to go. Let’s build one. The question: How does Dickens present Scrooge as an outsider in A Christmas Carol? Not yet a thesis: Scrooge is an outsider in A Christmas Carol.

That’s a fact. Nobody could disagree with it. Getting there: Dickens presents Scrooge as an outsider who shuts himself away from other people. A clear claim, but no purpose. Strong: Dickens presents Scrooge’s isolation as his own choice, in order to show readers that selfishness cuts people off from the warmth of other people.

Top level: Dickens presents Scrooge as an outsider by choice, yet hints that he can still be reached; in doing so, he warns wealthy readers and persuades them that change is possible. Listen to what changed. The top-level thesis has a claim, a complication and a purpose, and every paragraph of the essay now has a job: prove one part of that sentence. Here are three more, for other set texts. In Macbeth, Shakespeare presents Macbeth’s ambition as a force that destroys his conscience, in order to warn his audience that disrupting the natural order leads to chaos.

In An Inspector Calls, Priestley presents the Inspector as the voice of social responsibility, in order to persuade his post-war audience to reject the selfishness of the Birlings. In ‘Ozymandias’, from the Power and Conflict cluster, Shelley presents human power as temporary, in order to show that even the proudest ruler is humbled by time. Your turn. Here are five questions. Pause the video and write a thesis for each.

Start with the Securing frame if you need it, then try to add a purpose and a complication. One: How does Dickens present the importance of family in A Christmas Carol? Two: How does Dickens use the Ghost of Christmas Yet to Come to frighten Scrooge into changing? Three: How does Shakespeare present Lady Macbeth as a powerful woman? Four: How does Shakespeare present guilt in Macbeth?

Five: How does Priestley present Sheila as a character who changes? Then check each one. Does it answer the question that was asked? Does it use the words of the question? Does it make an argument someone could disagree with?

Does it name the writer’s purpose? And will every paragraph you plan support it? The Thesis Statement Builder is free to download and print at btl.education. Keep it next to you every time you plan an essay. Thank you for watching.

Twelve weeks to GCSE English: the Year 11 revision countdown 4:35Plays from YouTube once you press play. Watch it on YouTube
Read the transcript

Twelve weeks before your first English exam is the right moment to start a plan, and this is ours. It’s called the Year 11 countdown, it’s free to download and print, and in this video I’ll take you through it week by week. I’m Hannah, and I teach English. One focus a week. About thirty minutes a day, five days a week.

That’s all it asks. Every week runs the same way. Days 1 and 2: retrieve. Write down everything you remember about the focus, then check your notes and fill the gaps in a different colour. Test yourself on quotations.

Days 3 and 4: practise. Plan an answer to an exam-style question in ten minutes, then write two What–How–Why paragraphs from your plan. Day 5: time yourself. Write one full answer in exam time, then mark it against the level descriptors or ask your teacher for feedback. Retrieve first, because what you can remember without your notes is what you’ll have in the exam.

Then practise, then time yourself. The order matters. Here are the twelve weeks. The countdown uses Macbeth, A Christmas Carol and An Inspector Calls as its set texts; if you study different ones, swap yours in. Week 12: Macbeth: plot and characters.

Retell the play act by act from memory; one character profile a day. Week 11: Macbeth: themes, context and quotations. Learn ten quotations; link each one to a theme and to Jacobean context. Week 10: A Christmas Carol: plot, characters and context. Retell the five staves; revise the Poor Law, Malthus and Dickens’s purpose.

Week 9: A Christmas Carol: themes and quotations. Learn ten quotations; write one timed extract-to-whole essay. Week 8: An Inspector Calls: plot, characters and context. Retell the play; revise 1912 and 1945, class, age and gender. Week 7: An Inspector Calls: themes and quotations.

Learn ten quotations; write one timed essay. Week 6: Power and Conflict: the first eight poems. One poem a day: its context, three quotations and one method each. Week 5: Power and Conflict: the last seven poems and comparison. Finish the anthology; plan three comparisons that pair poems by theme.

Week 4: Unseen poetry. Practise the single-poem question and the comparison question on new poems. Week 3: Language Paper 1. Reading questions 1 to 4 on a fiction extract; one descriptive or narrative piece. Week 2: Language Paper 2.

Reading questions 1 to 4 on two non-fiction sources; one viewpoint piece. Week 1: Final week. Read through your notes and quotation lists, do short timed tasks only, and get plenty of sleep. In 2027 your four English papers are spread over four weeks: Literature Paper 1 on Wednesday 12 May, Literature Paper 2 on Wednesday 19 May, Language Paper 1 on Monday 24 May and Language Paper 2 on Tuesday 8 June. After each paper, spend about thirty minutes a day on the next one only.

From 12 to 18 May, Literature Paper 2: An Inspector Calls quotations, one Power and Conflict comparison plan a day, and one unseen poem in forty-five minutes. From 19 to 23 May, Language Paper 1: reread your Week 3 notes, practise Questions 2 to 4 on a new fiction extract, and plan one Question 5 a day. From 24 May to 7 June, Language Paper 2: practise Questions 1 to 4 on pairs of non-fiction sources, write one timed viewpoint piece a week, and do one full paper in an hour and forty-five minutes in the last week. And the night before an English exam. Read through your quotation lists once.

Leave new material alone. Pack at least two black pens in a see-through pencil case. You may highlight the question paper but not your answers. Watches aren’t allowed in the exam room, so plan to time yourself by the room clock. Remind yourself of the timings for each question on the paper.

There’s a table at the bottom of the countdown to write them in. And go to bed at your usual time. The Year 11 countdown is free at btl.education, along with a guide for parents and carers and the Thesis Statement Builder. Print it, stick it on the wall, and tick each week off. Good luck.

Thank you for watching.

Press / to search from any page, and Esc to close.